FH Stralsund - Leisure and Tourism  Management
Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Arlt WS 2004/2005

 

You are on www.arlt-lectures.com

Best viewed with Internet Explorer

How to print-out this page

 

 TI

 Tourism Impact

 

 

 "Tourism Impacts" will deal with the results of the development of tourism as a mass phenomenon in the last century.

 How is tourism changing the world in social, economic and last but not least ecological ways?

 

 Tourism takes place in physical surroundings, but is an important part of reality production in post-modern societies.

 

 Today it can be said that tourism creates the world according to it's needs.

 

To understand this better let's briefly compare the development of the last century, i.e. the development from industrial to post-industrial (or modern to post-modern) world and elite tourism to mass tourism, looking at the three components of "Sustainability":

economic (incl. physical),
social and
ecological aspects

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sustainability in Leisure and Tourism

 

 The 20th century has seen remarkable advances in the development of science and technology and in social productivity. The abundant material wealth created by mankind is unprecedented and it has resulted in a rapid development of civilization.

However, aggravations caused by population expansion, excessive consumption of resources and global environmental problems such as pollution, reduced biodiversity and increased gap between north and south, have seriously hampered the development of economies and improvements in people's quality of life, and are even threatening human existence itself.

Given the pressures of these harsh realities, mankind has no choice but to re-examine its social and economic behavior and its path of development. Traditional ideas of considering economic growth solely in quantitative terms and the traditional development mode of "polluting first and treating later" are no longer appropriate when considering present and future requirements for development.

It is now necessary to find a path for development, wherein considerations of population, economy, society, natural resources, and the environment are coordinated as a whole, so that a path for non-threatening sustainable development can be found which will meet current needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs.

 

Sustainability - What does it mean?

 

sus·tain·abil·i·ty [s&s-'stA-n&-'bi-l&-tE] noun
1: capability of being sustained; 2a: of, relating to, or being a method of harvesting or using a resource so that the resource is not depleted or permanently damaged <sustainable techniques> <sustainable agriculture> b: of or relating to a lifestyle involving the use of sustainable methods <sustainable society> 
circa 1727 
Merriam-Webster

Careful! Differences in different languages: f.i. Nachhaltigkeit, Durabilité, Naiyong

 

 

 

Nachhaltigkeit:

Der Begriff der Nachhaltigkeit stammt ursprünglich aus der Forstwirtschaft und wurde erstmals um ca. 1700 vom Oberberghauptmann Hans Carl von Carlowitz in der Silberstadt Freiberg (Sachsen) "erfunden". Auch hier war der neue Begriff der Nachhaltigkeit ein Kind der Krise: nicht etwa die Erschöpfung der Silberlager- stätten sondern die sich schnell verschärfende Holzknappheit veranlasste den adeligen Forstmann zur Erarbeitung eines Nachhaltigkeitskonzepts zur dauerhaften Bereitstellung ausreichender Holzmengen für den Silberbergbau. Nachhaltigkeit in der Forstwirtschaft bezeichnet eine Art und Weise der Holzwirtschaft, bei der der Waldbestand als natürliche Ressource für die Holzwirtschaft auf Dauer gesichert bleibt. So wird z.B. immer nur soviel Holz geschlagen, wie durch Wiederaufforstung nachwachsen kann

Ulrich Grober: "Der Erfinder der Nachhaltigkeit. http://www.learn-line.nrw.de/angebote/agenda21/archiv/99/pr/zei4898nachhalt.htm
DIE ZEIT, Nr.48/25.11.99, S.98]

 

 

Definitions:

Standard Definition:

Brundtland Report (World Commission on Environment & Development)
Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.

 

US President's Council on Sustainable Development:
"Sustainable development is economic growth that will benefit present and future generations without detrimentally affecting the resources or biological systems of the planet. A sustainable United States will have a growing economy that provides equitable opportunities for satisfying livelihoods and a safe, healthy, high quality of life for current and future generations. Our nation will protect its environment, its natural resource base, and the functions and viability of natural systems on which all life depends."

 

David Schaller (Sustainable Development Coordinator for the Denver Regional Office of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency)
Achieving the ecological balance which allows economic prosperity and social equity to be achieved across generations.

 

Muscoe Martin, Author of: "A Sustainable Community Profile
The word sustainable has roots in the Latin subtenir, meaning 'to hold up' or 'to support from below.' A community must be supported from below - by its inhabitants, present and future. Certain places, through the peculiar combination of physical, cultural, and, perhaps, spiritual characteristics, inspire people to care for their community. Theses are the places where sustainability has the best chance of taking hold.

 

The three dimensions of Sustainability:

 

"3 P": Planet, People, Profit

 

A fourth dimension: Institutions

 

 

 

 

Sustainability in L&T - economical

 

Statement by BASF company (http://www.basf.de/en/corporate/sustainability/oekonomie/):

"What is meant by the economic dimension of sustainability? The goal of business activities (in a market economy, WA) is to generate high profits by making optimal use of resources, to ensure long-term competitive success and to increase corporate value. The principle of sustainability has the goal of balancing the economic, environmental and social needs of todays society without impairing the development opportunities of future generations. In many ways, the two goals support one another."    

Statement by World Business Council on Sustainable Development (http://www.wbcsd.ch):
"Sustainable development involves the simultaneous pursuit of economic prosperity, environmental quality and social equity. Companies aiming for sustainability need to per
form not against a single, financial bottom line but against the triple bottom line."

LET'S DISCUSS THIS TWO STATEMENTS!   

 

 

 

 

Tourism industry is much more interested in the protection of environment and heritage than other industries.

Why is it more important from an economical point of view for a destination to care about this questions then let's say for an automobile manufacturer?

Economic sustainability in L&T also has an important Human Resource Management aspect.

What is the impact of the concept of economic sustainability on HRM?

 

 

 

Sustainability in Leisure and Tourism - ecological dimension

 

The three dimensions of Sustainability:

 

http://www.hawaiitourismstudy.com/

 

Leisure and Tourism creating environmental problems

Overview (Dot = area where tourism is creating problems, arrow upward = level of problems increasing)

From: http://themes.eea.eu.int/Sectors_and_activities/tourism/indicators/signal01_chap4.pdf

For instance:

Direct influences:

Leisure and Tourism activities taking place in areas which otherwise would not be touched by man (high mountains, coral reefs, caves, remote islands), making building of roads necessary, pollute the area, bring waste problems etc..

Leisure and Tourism activities destroy ecosystems by overuse (2nd homes in Europe, Himalaja etc.)

Leisure and Tourism activities cost much more energy and water than staying at home / use of locals through watering of golf courses etc., swimming-pool, air-condition etc.

Indirect influences:

Travelling increases pollution from cars, planes etc.

Energy usages and pollution increases effect on atmosphere etc.

 

 Leisure and Tourism solving environmental problems

 

As the tourism industry is itself interested to keep the environment from deterioration, it is defending itself by showing the positive effects of tourism, f.i. in the cleaning of water pollution in the mediterranean sea:

 

 

 

 

 

 Four different option for ecological policies supporting sustainable tourism:

Information about eco-damages and appeals to the eco-consciousness

Tax reductions and financial support of eco-friendly behavior

Direct government intervention (building water treatment systems, buying from eco-friendly producers etc.)

Eco-laws and -rules (Emission level ceilings, Protected Areas etc.) and Sanctions for violation of laws and rules

 

 

Which of these policies do you regard as most successful?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Is sustainable tourism just a

marketing tool to hide the negative effects of global tourism

or a

real chance?

 

One half of the group is supporting the first view, the second half the other view.

Please discuss!

 

 

 

 

 

 Contact: wolfgang.arlt@fh-stralsund.de, Office: Hs. 1 / Rm. 132,
 Tel. (03831) 45 6961 (FHS), (0179) 705 24 51 (mobile)

home.gif